|
ECONOMIC
DATA / NEWS Wednesday 9/21/2009
Liquidity Exists
First, let it be known that liquidity does exist. The
capital markets are evolving rapidly, with players entering
and exiting weekly. The market is highly inefficient,
and locating capital demands a lot of ground work. Those
with real capacity and discretion are few and far between;
most are only pretending to be active to protect their
brand. But the truth is revealed when the best opportunities
are presented and excuses are eliminated. In
this way, the real players are starting to surface.
A select group of lenders and institutional equity investors
do indeed have capital; whats more, they want
to deploy it.
However, capital has almost universally been out of
the game for 12-24 months, and it is very cautious about
re-entry; the first deal in 12-18 months is going to
have to be nearly perfect. Capital has to be compelled
in order to overcome endemic stand-still inertia.
Economic Underwriting
It goes without saying that the underwriting treatment
for both debt and equity is radically more conservative
today. Weve all seen deals killed by conservative
assumptions. For example, we recently note:
Rents marked down to a very conservative estimate of
market rent;
Conservative underwriting adjustments for total cost
of occupancy, considering RUBS, NNN expenses, capital
costs, etc.;
Vacancy underwritten at the higher of 10% or actual-market
(rather than the traditional 5%), with careful attention
to direct versus sublet space, economic versus physical
occupancy, and concessions;
Conservative allowances for re-tenanting in terms of
cost and absorption rate; and
Draconian exit cap-rate assumptions.
Compelling Opportunities
In additional to these types of baseline economic hurdles,
and inertia holding the investor at a stand-still, the
successful deal will be compelling. This
includes:
Best-in-class sponsorship with a long track record
of success in the specific subject market and product
type;
Making money on the buy, where the dollar-per-pound
project costs represent a significant discount to replacement
cost; and
Safe foundation of cash-flow, where a conservative
estimate of stabilized NOI over costs is higher than
a reasonable exit cap-rate assumption.
Risk-Mitigation
In addition to being compelled, capital also demands
supplementary risk-mitigation measures to satisfy extreme
risk-aversion, such as:
Conservative business plans, including the capacity,
investment horizon and debt term to safely carry
the project in a down-side scenario for 5 years;
Underwriting sponsor liquidity to solve problems, exposure
to maturities in their existing portfolio, and legacy
portfolio risks;
Carefully considering the availability of capital to
support the exit, and investing only where they can
confidently predict a take-out financing or buyer liquidity;
Selecting stable or recovering markets, or building
in a significant cushion for further deterioration.
Caution Over Speed
Whats more, capital wont be rushed. Decisions
are made by committee. In the good-old-days, a well
connected intermediary could make the call
for a quick thumbs-up / thumbs-down from the key decision
maker, with 80-90% accuracy. Today, a diverse panel
of stake-holders is consulted. Diligence is thorough.
The fact set must be complete. All eventualities must
be considered. Risks must be defined and mitigated.
The deal should expect to wait for the money.
This reality is frustrating, because the perfect
deal, by definition, is distressed
and therefore trading on a short fuse. So whats
a deal-maker to do? Prepare.
Thanks
for your business and have a good week.
P.S. We
are still lending; now more than ever you need a
commercial loan broker to get your deal done right.
Wes Lewison,
Investment Property Specialist (949)
218-4007 Direct
|